Which Cinnamon Is Safe? Lead, Coumarin, and How We Chose the Best for MERIA CHAI

Which Cinnamon Is Safe? Lead, Coumarin, and How We Chose the Best for MERIA CHAI

Ingredient Integrity · Clean Chai Journal

Cassia vs. Ceylon — Understanding the Real Health Trade-Off

“The real debate isn’t which cinnamon tastes better — it’s which one’s toxins your body can actually process.”

When developing Meria Chai, we assumed Ceylon cinnamon would be the obvious “healthier” choice. It’s often praised for its low coumarin content — a natural plant compound that, in large doses, can strain the liver. But during sourcing, we uncovered a surprising truth: Cassia cinnamon was consistently the cleanest and most transparent option when it came to lead content.

Ceylon suppliers rarely shared heavy-metal results, while the Cassia supplier we ultimately chose provided full batch documentation with verified low lead levels. That discovery reframed the question entirely.

The Real Choice: Coumarin vs. Lead

The debate isn’t “Ceylon or Cassia?” — it’s “Which health risk matters more: coumarin or lead?”

Coumarin is a natural aromatic compound that the body can metabolize through liver enzymes (primarily CYP2A6) into 7-hydroxycoumarin, which is then excreted in urine. Unless consumed in extremely high doses — multiple teaspoons of Cassia daily — it does not accumulate or cause harm in healthy individuals.[EFSA 2008]

Lead, in contrast, is a toxic heavy metal with no safe level of exposure.[CDC] The body cannot break it down or excrete it effectively. Instead, lead accumulates in bones, organs, and the nervous system, where it can cause lasting neurological and developmental damage even at trace levels.

“Your liver can process coumarin. It cannot process lead.”

How to Prioritize Safety

When choosing cinnamon, think in order of toxicological priority:

  1. Minimize Lead Exposure — Lead is cumulative and irreversible. Always favor suppliers who publish verified batch heavy-metal test results.
  2. Then Consider Coumarin — Once lead safety is confirmed, choose lower-coumarin varieties if you use large daily amounts. Coumarin risk is dose-dependent, and normal spice use stays well below the EFSA TDI of 0.1 mg/kg body weight/day.
In short:
Ceylon = low coumarin, but often undisclosed lead content.
Cassia = higher coumarin, but transparent and tested for lead.

If you must choose, choose data over assumption.

The Science in Simple Terms

Coumarin

  • 🌿 Natural aromatic compound in Cassia
  • 🧠 Metabolized by liver enzymes (CYP2A6)
  • ☕ Risk only at high, chronic intake
  • ✅ Non-cumulative — excreted through urine

Lead

  • ⚠️ Toxic heavy metal — no safe dose
  • 🧠 Accumulates in bone and organs
  • ⏳ Causes long-term neurological harm
  • 🚫 Cannot be metabolized or excreted efficiently

Why Transparency Wins

In practice, the safest cinnamon isn’t necessarily the one with the best marketing — it’s the one whose lab reports you can read. A Ceylon supplier that won’t disclose lead data leaves you guessing. A Cassia supplier that provides full, third-party documentation offers measurable safety.

This is why Meria Chai is built on verified sourcing rather than assumptions. We believe if you’re going to spend your time and energy creating something, it should be beneficial, not harmful — from the ground up. Every product we make begins with the same question: what would the best version of this look like if we refused to cut corners?

That commitment means doing the research others skip, choosing integrity over margin, and standing by the science even when it challenges trends. Because what we consume daily should nurture us — not quietly harm us.

“The healthiest cinnamon isn’t defined by its name — it’s defined by its honesty.”
Back to blog